HR disciplinary procedures guide for UK employers

HR disciplinary procedures help employers deal with misconduct, poor performance and workplace concerns fairly.

When disciplinary action is handled badly, it can damage trust, affect morale and increase the risk of employment tribunal claims. A clear disciplinary procedure helps both the employer and employee understand the process, the evidence, the possible outcomes and the right to appeal.

This guide explains how the disciplinary process works, what a fair disciplinary procedure should include, and how HR teams can manage disciplinary cases in line with good employment law practice.

Key takeaways

  • HR disciplinary procedures help employers deal with employee misconduct, poor performance and workplace concerns fairly.
  • A fair disciplinary procedure should include investigation, written allegations, a disciplinary hearing, a reasoned decision and an appeals process.
  • Employers should follow the Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures in England, Scotland and Wales.
  • Disciplinary action should be reasonable, proportionate and based on evidence.
  • Employees should usually be allowed to give their side of the story before formal disciplinary action is taken.
  • Gross misconduct can lead to dismissal, but the employer must still follow a fair procedure.
  • Poor disciplinary handling can increase the risk of unfair dismissal claims, compensation uplifts and legal disputes.

What is a disciplinary procedure?

A disciplinary procedure is the formal process an employer follows when there are concerns about an employee’s conduct, behaviour or performance.

It sets out how the employer will:

  • Raise concerns
  • Investigate allegations
  • Gather evidence
  • Invite the employee to a disciplinary hearing
  • Let the employee respond
  • Decide whether disciplinary action is needed
  • Confirm the outcome in writing
  • Offer a right of appeal

A disciplinary procedure helps ensure employees are treated fairly and consistently. It also helps employers show that any formal disciplinary action was handled reasonably.

Disciplinary procedures should be clear, accessible and shared with employees. They may be included in the employee’s contract, staff handbook or workplace policy documents.

Why disciplinary procedures matter

Disciplinary procedures matter because they protect both the employer and employee.

For employers, a fair disciplinary process can help:

  • Deal with misconduct fairly
  • Address poor performance
  • Maintain workplace standards
  • Reduce the risk of legal claims
  • Support consistent decision making
  • Protect the organisation’s reputation
  • Show reasonable behaviour if a case reaches an employment tribunal

For employees, a fair process helps ensure they:

  • Understand the allegations
  • See the evidence
  • Have time to prepare
  • Can explain their side of the story
  • Can bring a companion where the right applies
  • Receive the employer’s decision in writing
  • Have the opportunity to appeal

The aim is not simply to punish employees. A good disciplinary process should help establish what happened, decide whether further action is needed and resolve workplace issues fairly.

Disciplinary and grievance procedures

Disciplinary and grievance procedures are linked, but they deal with different issues.

A disciplinary procedure is usually started by the employer. It deals with concerns about an employee’s conduct, capability or behaviour.

A grievance procedure is usually started by the employee. It deals with complaints or concerns raised by the employee, such as unfair treatment, bullying, discrimination, workload or a workplace dispute.

Sometimes both processes overlap.

For example:

  • An employee raises a grievance during a disciplinary process.
  • A disciplinary case involves complaints from other employees.
  • A grievance investigation identifies possible misconduct.
  • An employee says the disciplinary process is unfair or biased.

Where this happens, the employer should decide whether to pause the disciplinary process, deal with the grievance first, or run both processes in parallel. The decision should be fair, documented and aligned with the employer’s procedures.

The Acas Code and employment law

In England, Scotland and Wales, employers should follow the Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures.

The Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures sets out principles for handling disciplinary and grievance matters fairly. Employment tribunals can take the Code into account when deciding relevant claims.

If either side unreasonably fails to follow the Code, tribunal compensation can be increased or reduced by up to 25%.

A fair disciplinary procedure under the Acas Code should usually include:

  • Establishing the facts
  • Informing the employee of the problem in writing
  • Holding a disciplinary hearing
  • Giving the employee a chance to answer allegations
  • Allowing the employee to be accompanied where the right applies
  • Deciding on appropriate disciplinary action
  • Giving the employee the right to appeal

Employers in Northern Ireland should follow the relevant Northern Ireland rules and Labour Relations Agency guidance, as different procedures apply.

UK jurisdiction differences

Employment law is not identical across all parts of the UK, so employers should be clear about which jurisdiction applies before managing disciplinary and grievance procedures.

For employers in England, Scotland and Wales , disciplinary and grievance procedures should follow the Acas Code of Practice. Employment tribunals can take the Acas Code into account, and compensation may be increased or reduced by up to 25% if either side unreasonably fails to follow it.

For employers in Northern Ireland , Acas guidance does not apply in the same way. Northern Ireland has its own employment law framework, and employers should follow Labour Relations Agency guidance and the relevant Northern Ireland disciplinary and grievance procedures.

This distinction matters because tribunal routes and terminology can differ. In Great Britain, claims are usually heard by an employment tribunal. In Northern Ireland, workplace disputes may be handled through an Industrial Tribunal or Fair Employment Tribunal, depending on the type of claim.

If your organisation operates across more than one UK jurisdiction, your disciplinary policy should make clear which process applies to each workplace. HR teams should also take local advice before managing complex disciplinary cases, dismissals or appeals.

Informal action before a formal disciplinary process

Taking formal disciplinary action should usually be a last resort.

In many cases, concerns can be resolved informally first. This may be suitable where the issue is minor, early-stage or unlikely to justify a formal sanction.

Informal action may include:

  • A quiet word with the employee
  • Coaching
  • Additional training
  • Clarifying expectations
  • Setting targets
  • Regular check-ins
  • Support from a manager
  • A note of concern
  • Mediation, where appropriate

For example, if an employee is occasionally late or has made a minor mistake, informal action may be enough.

However, informal action may not be suitable where the issue is serious, repeated or involves allegations such as bullying, harassment, theft, fraud, violence or gross misconduct.

Managers should keep brief records of informal action. This helps show what support was offered if the issue continues.

Misconduct vs poor performance

Before starting a disciplinary process, employers should decide what type of issue they are dealing with.

Misconduct usually relates to behaviour or conduct. Examples may include:

  • Bullying
  • Harassment
  • Repeated lateness
  • Unauthorised absence
  • Refusing reasonable instructions
  • Breaching workplace rules
  • Inappropriate behaviour
  • Misuse of company property
  • Breach of confidentiality

Poor performance usually relates to an employee’s ability to do the job to the required standard.

Poor performance may be linked to:

  • Lack of training
  • Unclear expectations
  • Health issues
  • Workload
  • Lack of support
  • Skills gaps
  • New responsibilities
  • Capability concerns

Some employers handle poor performance through a separate capability procedure. Others manage it through the disciplinary procedure. Either way, the process should be fair, supportive and reasonable.

Where performance is the issue, employers should usually consider support, training and realistic improvement timescales before moving to formal disciplinary action.

Gross misconduct

Gross misconduct is very serious misconduct that may justify dismissal without notice.

Examples may include:

  • Theft
  • Fraud
  • Physical violence
  • Serious bullying or harassment
  • Serious breach of health and safety rules
  • Serious insubordination
  • Gross negligence
  • Serious breach of confidentiality
  • Serious misuse of company systems
  • Behaviour that seriously damages the organisation

The employee’s contract, staff handbook or disciplinary policy should give examples of what the organisation treats as gross misconduct.

However, even where gross misconduct is alleged, the employer must still follow a fair disciplinary procedure. This means investigating, giving the employee written details of the allegations, holding a disciplinary hearing and considering all the evidence before deciding on a sanction.

Dismissal should never be automatic.

The disciplinary process step by step

A fair disciplinary process should be structured, documented and handled without unreasonable delay.

1. Decide whether formal action is needed

The employer should first decide whether the concern needs formal disciplinary action.

Ask:

  • What happened?
  • Is this misconduct, poor performance or something else?
  • Is informal resolution suitable?
  • Has the employee been spoken to before?
  • Is there a workplace rule or policy involved?
  • Could training or support resolve the concern?
  • Is the allegation serious enough for formal action?
  • Is suspension being considered, and is it necessary?

The employer should avoid rushing into a formal process without understanding the issue.

2. Carry out an investigation

An investigation helps establish the facts before the employer decides whether there is a disciplinary case to answer.

The investigation process may include:

  • Reviewing documents
  • Speaking to witnesses
  • Reviewing emails or messages
  • Checking CCTV or system records, where appropriate
  • Reviewing workplace policies
  • Checking the employee’s contract
  • Considering previous records
  • Speaking to the employee where appropriate
  • Gathering all the evidence fairly

The investigation should be impartial and balanced. It should look for evidence that supports the allegation and evidence that may support the employee’s side of the story.

Where possible, the person investigating should be different from the person chairing the disciplinary hearing.

3. Consider suspension only where necessary

Suspension may be considered in serious cases, but it should not be automatic.

It may be appropriate where:

  • There is a serious allegation of gross misconduct
  • There is a risk to employees, customers or the business
  • Evidence could be affected
  • Witnesses could be influenced
  • Working relationships have broken down temporarily

Suspension should usually be on full pay, kept as short as possible and reviewed regularly.

The employer should confirm suspension in writing and make clear that it is not disciplinary action or a decision that the employee is guilty.

Employers should also consider alternatives to suspension, such as temporary changes to duties, reporting lines or working arrangements.

4. Decide if there is a disciplinary case to answer

After the investigation, the employer should decide whether there is enough evidence to move to a disciplinary hearing.

Possible decisions include:

  • No further action
  • Informal action
  • Additional support or training
  • Mediation
  • Moving to a formal disciplinary hearing
  • Taking other management action

If there is no disciplinary case to answer, the process should end and the employee should be told.

If the employer decides a formal disciplinary hearing is needed, the employee should be informed in writing.

5. Send a disciplinary hearing letter

The disciplinary hearing letter should give the employee enough information to prepare.

It should usually include:

  • The allegations in detail
  • The possible consequences
  • The date, time and location of the disciplinary hearing
  • Who will attend
  • Copies of relevant evidence
  • The employee’s right to be accompanied
  • How to submit evidence
  • Whether witnesses may be called
  • Who to contact with questions

The letter should be clear and specific. Vague allegations make it harder for the employee to prepare and can weaken the fairness of the process.

The employee should be given reasonable time to prepare before the meeting.

6. Hold the disciplinary hearing

The disciplinary hearing is the formal meeting where the employer explains the allegations and the employee has the opportunity to respond.

At the hearing, the employer should:

  • Explain the purpose of the meeting
  • Go through the allegations
  • Review the evidence
  • Allow the employee to answer questions
  • Allow the employee to give their side of the story
  • Consider any evidence from the employee
  • Allow relevant questions where appropriate
  • Listen carefully
  • Avoid making a rushed decision

The employee should be treated respectfully, even where the allegations are serious.

The hearing should usually be adjourned before a decision is made. This gives the employer time to consider the evidence properly.

7. Allow the employee to be accompanied

In formal disciplinary hearings, employees and workers usually have the right to be accompanied where the meeting could result in a formal warning, other disciplinary action, or confirmation of a warning or action at appeal.

The companion may be:

  • A trade union representative
  • A trade union official
  • A workplace colleague

The companion can support the employee, address the meeting and confer with them. They should not usually answer questions on the employee’s behalf.

Employers should check the employee’s contract, disciplinary policy and any collective agreement, as these may provide additional rights.

8. Consider all the evidence

Before deciding on disciplinary action, the employer should consider all the evidence.

This includes:

  • The investigation findings
  • The employee’s response
  • Witness evidence
  • Documents and records
  • Relevant policies
  • The employee’s length of service
  • Previous disciplinary record
  • Any mitigating factors
  • Consistency with similar cases
  • Whether further action is reasonable

The employer should not base the decision on assumptions, personal dislike or pressure from other people.

The decision should be fair, proportionate and supported by evidence.

9. Decide on disciplinary action

After the hearing, the employer decides whether disciplinary action is appropriate.

Possible outcomes include:

  • No action
  • Informal warning
  • First written warning
  • Final written warning
  • Additional training
  • Mediation
  • Change to duties, where allowed
  • Demotion, where allowed
  • Dismissal with notice
  • Summary dismissal for gross misconduct

The sanction should match the seriousness of the issue.

For example, a minor first offence may justify a first written warning, while repeated misconduct or gross misconduct may justify stronger action.

Employers should check the employee’s contract before imposing sanctions such as demotion or transfer. If the contract does not allow it, imposing the sanction could create legal risk.

10. Confirm the outcome in writing

The employer’s decision should be confirmed in writing.

The outcome letter should usually include:

  • The allegations considered
  • The evidence reviewed
  • The decision
  • The reason for the decision
  • Any disciplinary sanction
  • The length of any warning
  • Expected improvement or behaviour
  • Any support or training
  • Consequences of further misconduct
  • The right to appeal
  • The appeal deadline

Clear writing is essential. The letter should explain what the employer decided and why.

11. Offer an appeal

The employee should have the right to appeal disciplinary action.

An appeal may be based on:

  • New evidence
  • A belief that the decision was wrong
  • Concerns about the investigation
  • Concerns about bias
  • Concerns that the sanction was too harsh
  • Failure to follow the formal procedure
  • Mitigating factors not being considered

The appeal should usually be made in writing.

Where possible, the appeal hearing should be chaired by someone independent and more senior than the original decision-maker. If this is not possible in a small organisation, the person hearing the appeal should act as impartially as possible.

The appeal outcome should be confirmed in writing and is usually the final internal stage.

Common disciplinary sanctions

Disciplinary action should be proportionate.

Common sanctions include:

  • Informal warning
  • First written warning
  • Final written warning
  • Dismissal with notice
  • Summary dismissal for gross misconduct

Other possible outcomes may include:

  • Training
  • Coaching
  • Mediation
  • A performance improvement plan
  • A change to duties
  • Demotion, if contractually allowed
  • Transfer, if contractually allowed

Employers should be consistent. Similar cases should usually be treated in a similar way unless there is a clear reason for a different outcome.

Fair disciplinary procedure checklist

Use this checklist to help manage a disciplinary case.

Before the hearing

  • Check the disciplinary policy.
  • Decide whether informal action is suitable.
  • Identify whether the issue is misconduct, poor performance or gross misconduct.
  • Appoint an impartial investigator.
  • Gather all the evidence.
  • Consider whether suspension is necessary.
  • Decide whether there is a disciplinary case to answer.
  • Send a clear disciplinary hearing letter.
  • Provide evidence in advance.
  • Allow reasonable time for the employee to prepare.

During the hearing

  • Explain the purpose of the meeting.
  • Go through the allegations.
  • Review the evidence.
  • Allow the employee to respond.
  • Let the employee tell their side of the story.
  • Allow questions where appropriate.
  • Consider mitigation.
  • Keep notes.
  • Avoid making a rushed decision.
  • Treat everyone respectfully.

After the hearing

  • Review all the evidence.
  • Check consistency with previous cases.
  • Decide whether disciplinary action is reasonable.
  • Confirm the outcome in writing.
  • Explain any sanction clearly.
  • Offer the right to appeal.
  • Store records securely.
  • Follow up on any support or training.
  • Monitor future conduct or performance.
  • Review lessons for the organisation.

Common mistakes employers should avoid

Employers should avoid these disciplinary procedure mistakes:

  • Skipping the investigation
  • Treating allegations as proven before the hearing
  • Not giving enough detail in writing
  • Failing to provide evidence
  • Refusing a reasonable companion request
  • Not allowing the employee to respond
  • Ignoring the employee’s explanation
  • Applying inconsistent sanctions
  • Delaying the process without good reason
  • Suspending automatically
  • Using disciplinary action for issues better handled through support
  • Not checking the employee’s contract
  • Failing to offer an appeal
  • Poor record keeping
  • Letting the same person manage every stage where this can be avoided

These mistakes can increase the risk of claims, compensation uplifts and damaged employee trust.

Disciplinary action and unfair dismissal

Disciplinary action can lead to dismissal in serious cases.

However, dismissal may be unfair if the employer fails to follow a fair procedure.

For example, there may be a risk of unfair dismissal if:

  • There was no proper investigation
  • The employee was not told the allegations clearly
  • The employee was not allowed to respond
  • The decision was pre-determined
  • The sanction was too harsh
  • Similar cases were treated differently
  • The employer ignored relevant evidence
  • The employee was not offered an appeal
  • The process breached the employer’s procedures

From 1 January 2027, the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal protection in England, Scotland and Wales will fall from two years to six months for dismissals taking effect on or after that date.

The existing cap on compensatory awards for unfair dismissal will also be removed.

This makes fair disciplinary procedures, manager training and accurate documentation even more important.

Employment tribunal risk

If a disciplinary case leads to dismissal or another serious outcome, the employee may decide to bring a claim to an employment tribunal.

Before making most tribunal claims, the employee must usually notify Acas and go through Early Conciliation.

Since 1 October 2026, the time limit for most employment tribunal claims in England, Scotland and Wales has been six months minus one day for workplace issues arising on or after that date.

For most issues that occurred before 1 October 2026, the previous three-month limit still applies. The longer limit for breach of contract claims in Scotland took effect on 9 November 2026.

The exact deadline depends on the type of claim and the circumstances. Internal disciplinary or grievance procedures do not pause tribunal time limits.

Employers should take advice where a disciplinary case is complex, high risk or involves dismissal, discrimination, whistleblowing, pregnancy, health issues or trade union activity.

What if an employee raises a grievance during a disciplinary process?

An employee may raise a grievance during a disciplinary process.

For example, they may allege:

  • Bullying
  • Discrimination
  • Bias
  • Unfair treatment
  • Poor management
  • A flawed investigation
  • Retaliation
  • Breach of procedure

The employer should consider the grievance carefully.

Depending on the circumstances, the employer may:

  • Pause the disciplinary process
  • Deal with the grievance first
  • Investigate both issues together
  • Continue both processes separately
  • Appoint a different manager to handle the grievance

The decision should be fair, reasonable and documented.

How HR can support disciplinary procedures

The HR function plays an important role in disciplinary cases.

HR can support by:

  • Creating disciplinary policies
  • Training managers
  • Advising on employment law
  • Helping assess risk
  • Supporting investigations
  • Preparing disciplinary hearing letters
  • Advising on fair procedure
  • Checking consistency
  • Supporting appeal arrangements
  • Keeping records secure
  • Advising on grievance procedures
  • Helping managers communicate clearly

HR should help ensure the process is fair to both the employee and employer. The role of HR is not to punish employees, but to support a lawful, consistent and reasonable process.

How e-Careers can support HR teams

Managing disciplinary procedures requires confidence in employment law, employee relations, investigation skills, documentation and difficult conversations.

e-Careers supports HR professionals, managers and employers through flexible online training designed to build practical workplace capability.

Our human resources courses can help learners strengthen their understanding of HR processes, workplace policies, employee relations, performance management and people practice.

For recognised professional development, our CIPD courses support learners across different stages of an HR career, from entry-level people practice to strategic HR and L&D progression.

Our CIPD Level 5 Associate Diploma in People Management is particularly relevant for HR professionals handling workplace disciplinary matters. Its Employment Relationship Management (5HR01) unit covers employee relations, conflict resolution, disciplinary procedures and grievance handling.

As a CIPD Platinum Centre, e-Careers has achieved the highest level of recognition awarded to a CIPD study centre. Learners on our online CIPD courses also benefit from a 99% pass rate, expert tutor support and flexible study designed around work and business needs.

Training can help HR teams and line managers apply disciplinary and grievance procedures more consistently, reduce risk and support fairer outcomes across the organisation.

Final thoughts

HR disciplinary procedures are essential for managing misconduct, poor performance and workplace concerns fairly.

A fair disciplinary procedure protects both the employer and employee. It helps establish the facts, gives the employee a chance to respond, supports consistent decisions and reduces the risk of legal claims.

The best approach is to act promptly, investigate properly, explain allegations clearly, hold a fair disciplinary hearing, consider all the evidence and offer a meaningful appeal.

For HR teams and managers, disciplinary cases can be challenging. Building employment law knowledge, communication skills and confidence in fair procedures can help organisations manage difficult situations professionally and protect workplace trust.

Frequently asked questions

What are HR disciplinary procedures?

HR disciplinary procedures are the formal steps employers use to deal with employee misconduct, poor performance or workplace concerns. They help ensure the process is fair, consistent and properly documented.

How long should a disciplinary procedure take?

There is no fixed statutory timeframe for completing a disciplinary procedure in Great Britain. However, employers should investigate concerns, arrange meetings and communicate decisions without unreasonable delay.

The length of the process depends on the complexity of the allegations, the evidence required and the circumstances of the case. Employees should be kept informed of any delays.

What is the disciplinary process?

The disciplinary process usually includes informal action where appropriate, investigation, a written disciplinary hearing invitation, a disciplinary hearing, an outcome letter and an appeal process.

What happens at a disciplinary hearing?

At a disciplinary hearing, the employer explains the allegations and evidence. The employee can respond, answer questions, present their side of the story and be accompanied where the right applies.

What is formal disciplinary action?

Formal disciplinary action may include a written warning, final written warning, dismissal with notice or summary dismissal for gross misconduct. The action should be reasonable and proportionate.

What is gross misconduct?

Gross misconduct is very serious misconduct that may justify dismissal without notice. Examples can include theft, fraud, violence, serious harassment, gross negligence or serious breach of workplace rules.

Can an employee bring a trade union representative to a disciplinary hearing?

Yes, where the statutory right applies, an employee or worker can be accompanied by a trade union representative, trade union official or workplace colleague.

What is a written warning?

A written warning is a formal disciplinary sanction that explains what the employee did wrong, what improvement is expected, how long the warning will remain active and what may happen if the issue continues.

Can an employee appeal disciplinary action?

Yes. Employees should have the right to appeal disciplinary action. An appeal hearing should usually be handled by someone impartial and, where possible, more senior than the original decision-maker.

Can a poor disciplinary process lead to an employment tribunal?

Yes. A poor disciplinary process can increase the risk of employment tribunal claims, including unfair dismissal claims. Tribunals may consider whether the employer followed the Acas Code and acted reasonably.

FREE Course Advice

By submitting this form, you agree to
e-Careers processing your data in line with our Privacy Policy

Contents

    Join the thousands of individuals, small businesses, and large corporations who trust e-Careers. ​

    Chat with our friendly experts today to discuss your training needs. ​
    Speak to a Course Consultant today

    Call us now on

    +44 (0) 20 3198 7700 Lines open 9am-6pm GMT (Mon-Fri)

    Alternatively, you can request a callback​

    Enquire Now
    Chat on WhatsApp